"Pool at the Edge of the Desert" by Frederick Goodall

Frederick Goodall, R.A.: A Victorian Orientalist’s Journey in Art

Introduction
Frederick Goodall, R.A. (1822–1904) was a prominent Victorian painter whose evocative scenes of Egypt and the Near East earned him renown as a leading figure in the Orientalist art movement. Best known for his luminous depictions of biblical and everyday life in North Africa, Goodall combined academic skill with first-hand travel experience to bring distant locales into vivid focus for British audiences.

In this in-depth exploration, we’ll trace Goodall’s life and artistic development, from his London upbringing and early successes to the transformative journeys along the Nile that inspired his Orientalist masterpieces. We’ll examine how his travels to Egypt shaped signature themes and techniques, allowing him to interpret daily life and architecture abroad with a unique blend of realism and romanticism.

Along the way, we’ll highlight major works – including A Pool at the Edge of the Desert – and see how paintings like The Finding of Moses and A Pool at the Edge of the Desert fit into his body of work. Finally, we’ll consider Goodall’s impact and legacy within Orientalist art and Victorian painting, reflecting on the enduring appeal of his imagery as well as the historical context and cultural lens through which it was created.

Early Photograph of Frederick Goodall
Early Photograph of Frederick Goodall

A Biographical Overview of Goodall

Frederick Goodall was born on 17 September 1822 in the St John’s Wood area of London as the second son of the noted steel engraver Edward Goodall. Growing up in a creative household, young Frederick received his artistic education at Wellington Road Academy and trained under the guidance of his father​. He showed precocious talent: at just 16 years old, Goodall painted a series of six watercolor views of the Thames Tunnel (commissioned by engineer Isambard Kingdom Brunel), four of which were exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1838. His very first oil painting earned him a silver medal from the Society of Arts that same year, affirming his potential.

Early Life and Artistic Development

"A Game of Draughts" by Goodall

Through the 1840s, Goodall built his reputation with genre scenes and pastoral landscapes drawn from travels around the British Isles and Europe. He sketched rural life in places like Normandy, Brittany, Ireland and Italy, producing works in the popular Wilkie tradition (after the artist David Wilkie) that featured peasant life and picturesque villages. A notable trip in 1843 through Ireland with fellow artist F. W. Topham provided material for several successful paintings. Goodall’s early mastery of detail and atmosphere in these scenes did not go unnoticed – he exhibited at the Royal Academy almost annually between 1838 and 1859. By age 30 he had been elected an Associate of the Royal Academy (ARA) in 1852, and in 1863 he attained the coveted status of Royal Academician (RA)​. These honors reflected his stature in the British art establishment, yet Goodall was only at the beginning of an evolution that would define his career.

By the mid-1850s, despite his success with domestic genre paintings, Goodall felt artistically “restricted” and yearned for new subjects and inspiration. The wider Victorian fascination with the Orient – fueled by biblical archaeology, travelogues, and imperial expansion – offered just the spark he needed. In 1858, Goodall made a bold decision to embark on a journey to Egypt, seeking fresh motifs and a grander narrative for his art. This fateful choice would transform him from a painter of English country life into one of the era’s most celebrated Orientalist artists.

Travels to Egypt: Inspiration for Orientalist Art

Goodall’s first journey to Egypt in 1858–1859 was undertaken with the explicit goal of gathering authentic material for biblical and Eastern themes. He later recounted that his “sole objective” for the trip was “to paint scriptural subjects” – a mission reflecting Victorian England’s profound interest in the Holy Land and Nile Valley as the backdrops of biblical history.

Armed with letters of introduction and accompanied by his friend, the Bavarian-born watercolorist Carl Haag, Goodall arrived in Cairo and immersed himself in the environment that would invigorate his imagination. He lived in the ancient Coptic quarter of Cairo with Haag, and together they spent months sketching street scenes, Islamic architecture, and everyday activities in and around the city​. The pair ventured into the desert outside Cairo as well, pitching tents near Giza where they could paint en plein air with the pyramids towering in the distance​.

Goodall was enthralled by what he saw: the graceful people, golden light, and monumental landscapes of Egypt provided “visual excitement” in abundance. He proved indefatigable in sketching everything from bustling bazaars to quiet Nile marshes, filling notebooks with studies that would inform his work for decades.

The immediate fruits of this Nile sojourn appeared when Goodall returned to England. In 1860 he exhibited Early Morning in the Wilderness of Shur at the Royal Academy – his first major painting drawn from Egyptian inspiration. The scene, drawn from the biblical Exodus narrative, featured a desert sunrise over a caravan and captured both the grandeur of the landscape and the ethnographic detail of Bedouin life. It was met with critical acclaim. Influential figures like Sir Edwin Landseer and the veteran Orientalist painter David Roberts praised Goodall’s work, impressed by its authenticity and atmosphere. This success firmly established Goodall’s reputation as an Orientalist painter. In fact, the demand for his Egyptian scenes was so high that the art dealer Ernest Gambart purchased all of Goodall’s oil sketches from the trip – for a hefty sum of six thousand guineas – giving the artist a small fortune and the means to travel again. 

Goodall's Second Egypt Trip (1870-1871)

Goodall indeed undertook a second journey to Egypt in 1870–1871, this time even more ambitiously immersing himself in the desert world. With proceeds from Gambart’s purchase financing him, Goodall spent three months living with a Bedouin tribe in the vicinity of Saqqara, not far from the pyramids of Giza​. He traveled with a local guide (dragoman) by donkey and brought along a custom portable sketch box – a gift from the French animal painter Rosa Bonheur – to facilitate painting in the field​.

By living in a Bedouin campsite, Goodall sought to directly observe the nomadic lifestyle: he rose with desert dawns, watched caravan encampments by flickering firelight, and noted rituals of daily prayer and pastoral work. The artist even went so far as to ship home live sheep and goats from Egypt to serve as models, ensuring that the textures and shapes in his studio paintings would be true to life. This almost obsessive commitment to authenticity became a hallmark of Goodall’s approach. Later writing of his adventures, he described camping under starry skies and gaining the trust of Bedouin companions – experiences that imbued his subsequent paintings with a rare degree of first-hand accuracy and empathy.

These two Egyptian expeditions – first in the late 1850s and again in 1870 – proved pivotal for Goodall. They supplied him with an archive of sketches and memories that he would mine for the rest of his career. After 1871, his studio in England became an exotic treasury of Near Eastern artifacts: he returned with costumes, carpets, ceramics, and of course the aforementioned livestock to serve as props in composing scenes​. Over the span of 46 years, Goodall exhibited roughly 170 paintings of Egyptian or Eastern subjects at the Royal Academy - a staggering output that testifies to how deeply Egypt had captured his imagination. As one contemporary noted, it was as an “Orientalist painter” that Goodall was henceforth “highly acclaimed”. The impact of his travels was evident in the richness of detail and confidence of vision in these works. Next, we will delve into the signature themes and techniques that characterize Goodall’s Orientalist art, shaped so profoundly by his Egyptian journeys.

Themes, Techniques, and Goodall’s Vision of Egypt

Goodall’s Orientalist works are distinguished by their warm tone of reverence and romantic realism, depicting the people and landscapes of Egypt with a blend of authenticity and idealization that appealed greatly to Victorian tastes. Several signature themes recur in his paintings:

"Flight of the Holy Family into Egypt" by Goodall
  • Biblical Episodes in an Oriental Setting: True to his original goal of painting scriptural subjects, Goodall frequently chose Old and New Testament scenes that take place in Egypt or the Holy Land. He populated these religious narratives with carefully observed details from his travels. For example, his The Finding of Moses (painted in versions of 1862 and 1885) portrays Pharaoh’s daughter discovering the infant Moses on the Nile, against a backdrop of Egyptian reeds, palms, and architecture that Goodall rendered with archaeological conscientiousness. Likewise, The Flight into Egypt (1884) – an enormous canvas over 4 meters wide, today in the Sarjeant Gallery in New Zealand – shows the Holy Family journeying through a sweeping desert landscape at twilight​. Goodall’s contemporaries admired how these works fused biblical drama with ethnographic realism, transporting viewers to the ancient Orient. One 1890s exhibition even featured 54 of his Egypt paintings under the title “Egypt and Life in the Valley of the Nile”​, emphasizing how Goodall had become an expert at interpreting sacred history through the lens of real Egyptian settings.
  • Daily Life and Pastoral Scenes: Many of Goodall’s most charming paintings depict the everyday life of Egyptian people – often focusing on the peaceful coexistence of humans, animals, and their environment. He was particularly drawn to pastoral and agrarian scenes along the Nile. Farmers (fellahin) ploughing fields, goat-herds grazing their flocks, women drawing water at a well, or families resting at an oasis are common motifs. Goodall’s A Pool at the Edge of the Desert exemplified this genre: it portrays travelers and livestock gathering at a tranquil desert oasis, suffused with golden light and the sense of respite that water brings to arid lands. In such works, Goodall took care to include recognizable landmarks or architecture to anchor the setting – often the pyramids or temple ruins looming in the distance, or the mudbrick walls of a village and palm trees under the Egyptian sun.
Avada-TextAndImage__Image
“Goatherd and Labourer near the Pyramids at Giza” (1884) by Frederick Goodall shows Egyptian peasants at work in the fertile edge of the desert, with the iconic pyramids on the horizon. Goodall’s firsthand observation of such scenes enabled him to paint them with striking authenticity and respect. Critics noted the “grace and nobility” he instilled in his Egyptian figures and the “sumptuous light, serenity, and peace” that infuse compositions like this one​. The grandeur of the landscape is balanced by intimate detail – from the patient oxen tilling the soil to the goats grazing by a shimmering pool – illustrating Goodall’s talent for harmonizing human activity with the vastness of the desert. The distant pyramids, rendered in subtle hazy profile, remind viewers of Egypt’s ancient continuity, a timeless backdrop against which modern life unfolds.
  • Architectural and Street Scenes: While Goodall favored open-air settings, he also depicted the architecture of Cairo and other locales when the subject called for it. His sketching sojourn in Cairo’s old quarters provided him with material on courtyards, arched alleys, and Islamic buildings. In Egyptian Pilgrims Arriving at an Inn (c.1867, Dahesh Museum of Art, New York), Goodall painted a weary caravan dismounting at a khan or roadside inn, capturing the play of light in a shaded courtyard and the intricate latticework on balconies.  His brother Edward Angelo Goodall, also an artist, painted the interiors of Cairo’s mosques, and this family interest in architecture informed Frederick’s careful rendering of background structures in many compositions​. Even when architecture isn’t the focal point, Goodall often included elements like the tents of a Bedouin camp, the minarets of a village mosque, or the sail of a felucca on the Nile, to enrich the sense of place. These details were executed with the same realist intent – based on sketches and perhaps photographs – lending credibility to scenes that might otherwise seem exotic to his audience.
  • Music and Cultural Traditions: Goodall occasionally highlighted local cultural practices, such as music and prayer, in his work. He was fascinated by the sounds of Egypt – from the call to prayer at sunset to folk musicians performing in market squares. One striking example is The Song of the Nubian Slave (also known as The Street Musician, 1864), which depicts an African musician playing a kissar (a lyre-like string instrument) on a Cairo street. Goodall likely encountered such performers during his evenings in Cairo, and he portrays the subject with dignity and rich coloration.
Avada-TextAndImage__Image
“The Kissar Player” (c.1859–1870) by Goodall is a wonderful vignette of a musician immersed in his art. The painting shows a Nubian man seated against a sun-baked wall in Cairo, plucking the strings of a triangular kissar adorned with feathers. Clad in a flowing blue galabeya and red turban, the musician is bathed in warm, ambient light. Goodall’s textured brushwork captures the worn surface of the plaster wall and the soft folds of fabric, conveying a quiet, intimate moment. In the lower right corner, he inscribed “Cairo” and the date, underscoring that this was drawn from life​. Works like this demonstrate Goodall’s empathy and interest in individual characters. Rather than caricature the “exotic,” he humanized his subjects – here, focusing on the soulful concentration of a man making music. The result is a painting that feels at once ethnographically specific and universally relatable. 
  • Spiritual and Ritual Moments: Another theme Goodall returned to was the spiritual life of the people he encountered. He was moved by displays of faith in daily routine – such as Muslims at prayer or pilgrims on a journey. In Evening Prayer in the Desert (also known as Abendgebet in der Wüste, 1872), Goodall portrayed a Bedouin man performing the maghrib (sunset) prayer on a rug laid atop the sand, while his family and camels repose by their tent in the gathering dusk​. The composition is spare and reverent: the sky glows with the last light of day as the figure stands facing the horizon in devotion.
Avada-TextAndImage__Image
“Evening Prayer in the Desert” (1872) by Goodall, displayed at the Kunsthalle Hamburg, exemplifies the artist’s gentle treatment of spiritual themes. There is a palpable tranquility in this scene – the encampment is settling for the night, and the praying figure is isolated in the open expanse, symbolizing a communion with the divine amidst nature. To Victorian viewers, such images had great aesthetic appeal: they were picturesque and “exotic,” yet also imbued with a moral or spiritual resonance. Critics of the time noted the serene piety in Goodall’s desert scenes as part of their beauty. The artist managed to convey a sense of peace that infuses the composition with a spiritual sensibility”, as one modern curator observed regarding his work. Goodall’s honest admiration for the devotion he witnessed helps explain why his Orientalist paintings often avoid the lurid or sensational tropes some of his contemporaries fell into. Instead, he presented Islamic and biblical devotions with a respectful, almost tender eye.

Technique and Style

Technically, Goodall was a master of academic oil painting, with a style rooted in realism but softened by a romantic palette. He worked up his major canvases in the studio from the myriad sketches and oil studies made on site. His use of light was especially celebrated – desert dawns and dusks in his paintings glow with pink and orange hues, and the strong Egyptian sun casts sharp shadows that give forms volume. Goodall had a keen eye for color and texture: one can almost feel the heat radiating off a mudbrick wall, the cool shade under a palm, or the rough hair of a camel in his works. He often applied paint in layers of thin glazes to achieve luminosity in skies and water, while using a thicker, textured application for foreground details like rocks or woven fabrics. This created a satisfying contrast that adds depth.

Goodall’s commitment to accuracy did not mean his paintings were dryly documentary – on the contrary, he selectively composed scenes to enhance their beauty or narrative clarity. He might rearrange figures or adjust a viewpoint for the sake of balance and emphasis. But because he had studied his subjects from life (even keeping live animals for reference), the end result remained convincing. He famously incorporated real Egyptian goats, sheep, and even donkeys into his English studio so that details in paintings – like the anatomically correct goat herd resting by the oasis in A Pool at the Edge of the Desert – would pass muster. Such dedication earned Goodall praise from fellow artists and critics for the truthfulness of his depictions​. Viewers felt they could trust the scenes he painted as faithful representations of the Orient, lending his work an almost educational value in addition to its artistry.

Major Works and Iconic Paintings

Throughout his long career, Goodall produced many noteworthy paintings, but a few stand out as iconic milestones that illustrate the range and significance of his oeuvre. Below, we highlight some of these major works, with context on how they fit into Goodall’s body of art:

"Early Morning in the Wilderness of Shur" by Goodall

Early Morning in the Wilderness of Shur (1860): This painting was Goodall’s first great Orientalist triumph, exhibited at the Royal Academy shortly after his initial Egypt trip. It depicts a scene from the Book of Exodus – Moses leading the Israelites through the Wilderness of Shur – rendered as a dawn landscape in the Egyptian desert. Pale sunlight breaks over distant hills as figures and camels traverse the sands in the foreground. Early Morning in the Wilderness of Shur earned immediate acclaim for its dramatic composition and fidelity to the desert atmosphere​. Sir Edwin Landseer lauded the piece, and it effectively put Goodall on the map as a painter of the biblical Orient. The success of this work was such that its oil sketches were highly sought; their sale helped fund Goodall’s return to Egypt in 1870. In retrospect, this painting can be seen as the foundation of Goodall’s mature period – combining religious narrative with the observational detail that would define his later work.

"The Finding of Moses" by Goodall

The Finding of Moses (1862 & 1885 versions): Goodall tackled the subject of baby Moses’ discovery by Pharaoh’s daughter multiple times, producing at least two major versions. The earlier, larger version (1862) was exhibited to great praise and eventually entered the collection of the Auckland Art Gallery in New Zealand. A later version from 1885 (slightly smaller) was sold into a private collection. In these paintings, Goodall brings to life the Nile riverbank with rich detail: the princess’s attendants, clad in flowing Oriental silks, gather around the reed basket containing the infant, while Egyptian architecture and palm trees rise in the background. What made Goodall’s Finding of Moses distinctive was his effort to archaeologically authenticate the setting – he included accurate Egyptian costumes, lotus blossoms on the Nile, and even hieroglyphic motifs, all informed by his studies in Egypt. Yet, he did not neglect the human element; the expressions and gestures of the figures create a moving tableau of surprise and compassion. This blend of the archaeological and the emotional in Goodall’s Finding of Moses exemplifies why Victorian collectors coveted his biblical scenes. They were not only devoutly themed but also exotic and visually splendid. Engravings after this painting circulated widely in the late 19th century, spreading Goodall’s fame beyond those who saw the originals.

"The Finding of Moses" by Lawrence Alma Tadema

The Flight into Egypt (1884): As mentioned earlier, The Flight into Egypt is one of Goodall’s largest and most ambitious works. At about 3.7 meters by 2.1 meters, it is a monumental canvas – so large that the Sarjeant Gallery in Whanganui has kept it on near-permanent display for over a century due to its size​. Goodall painted this in the 1880s, likely drawing on both imagination and memories of Sinai’s landscape. The painting shows Joseph leading a donkey carrying Mary and the Christ child, winding their way through a vast desert under a moonlit sky. The scale of the landscape almost dwarfs the Holy Family, emphasizing the arduousness of their journey but also the majesty of God’s creation enveloping them. Goodall’s handling of nocturnal light is masterful here – gentle blues and silvers illuminate the sand, and stars twinkle above, imparting a sacred atmosphere. The Flight into Egypt can be seen as a late-career culmination of Goodall’s biblical Orientalism. It synthesizes his decades of study: the accurate desert topography, the lovingly rendered Middle Eastern textiles on Mary’s attire, and the poignant humanity of the scene reflect an artist at the height of his powers. While Goodall painted many smaller Eastern scenes for the commercial market, this piece was a bold statement intended for exhibition. It earned him a place in the Exposition Universelle in Paris in 1900, where international audiences could admire it​. Even as tastes were beginning to shift by the 1880s, Goodall demonstrated with The Flight into Egypt that the Orientalist genre could achieve the grandeur of history painting.

"Oasis at the Edge of the Desert" by Goodall

A Pool at the Edge of the Desert (c.1870s): Among Goodall’s many pastoral Egyptian scenes, A Pool at the Edge of the Desert is often cited as a quintessential example. This panoramic composition (approximately 2 x 4 feet in size) shows a small oasis where desert meets fertile land. Although the painting is today in a private collection, its descriptions suggest a serene vista: possibly Bedouins watering their camels and goats at a pool, with dusk settling over distant dunes. Painted after Goodall’s second trip, it reflects the artist’s deep familiarity with Bedouin camp life. In Goodall’s body of work, A Pool at the Edge of the Desert fits into a series of tranquil desert landscapes that include Oasis in the Desert (Oasis près du Caire) and Morning in the Desert. These works share a peaceful, reflective mood – often illustrating the relief and community found around water in an arid environment. Compositionally, Goodall structures them with broad, horizontal layers (sky, desert, water), sometimes punctuated by a single tall palm or distant pyramid to catch the eye. A Pool at the Edge of the Desert and its kind were very popular with Victorian audiences, who admired their escapist beauty and the way Goodall’s brush seemingly transported them to a far-off, unspoiled Eden of the East. Today, when this piece appears at auction, it continues to attract fine art collectors drawn to Goodall’s idyllic vision of the desert.

"Evening Prayer in the Desert" by Goodall

Evening Prayer (Abendgebet) in the Desert (1872): Though we discussed this work in the context of theme, it also deserves note as a standalone masterpiece. Completed around 1872 (likely after his second trip), Evening Prayer in the Desert was exhibited in London and later found its way to Germany. The painting’s focus on a daily devotional act gave Victorian viewers a respectful glimpse into Muslim religious practice – something relatively novel in art at that time. Goodall’s portrayal of the praying Bedouin, with hands raised against the twilight sky, was widely praised for its serenity. This painting and others like Time for Prayer, Cairo (an 1881 scene of city dwellers pausing for prayer) highlight Goodall’s gentle narrative touch. Instead of grand biblical drama, these works find the sublime in simple moments of faith. They round out Goodall’s portfolio by showing that, beyond Bible stories and bustling market scenes, he also captured the contemplative, spiritual side of life in the East.

By the late 19th century, Goodall had created a diverse yet thematically coherent body of work. He was prolific – for instance, at the Royal Academy alone he showed over 170 paintings of Egypt and the Orient across four decades​. A number of his paintings were also reproduced as engravings or photographs, increasing their reach. Unfortunately, a considerable portion of Goodall’s output met a sad fate: many of his Egyptian paintings were destroyed in World War II bombings, as some had been kept in London galleries or storages that were hit during the Blitz. Despite these losses, the surviving works by Goodall continue to be held in esteem. Institutions such as the Russell-Cotes Art Gallery & Museum (Bournemouth, UK) hold examples like Subsiding the Nile, and the Dahesh Museum of Art (New York) proudly displays his Egyptian Pilgrims Arriving at an Inn. These paintings allow us to appreciate Goodall’s legacy firsthand, and they serve as cultural documents bridging Victorian Britain and nineteenth-century Egypt.

Impact and Legacy in Orientalist Art and Victorian Painting

Frederick Goodall’s impact on the art world of his time was significant. During the height of his career in the 1860s–1880s, he was one of Britain’s most celebrated painters of Eastern subjects, alongside other luminaries like John Frederick Lewis and the American expatriate Frederic Arthur Bridgman. Goodall’s canvases, with their blend of academic polish and travel-derived detail, helped set a standard for authenticity in Orientalist art. His works proved that scenes of North African life could command as much respect (and market value) as traditional European genres. By earning election to the Royal Academy and regularly contributing major Orientalist pictures to its annual exhibitions, Goodall brought what was once seen as an exotic or niche subject matter into the mainstream of Victorian art. Wealthy industrialists and even royalty sought out his paintings – at one point, Goodall was earning over £10,000 a year from his art, an enormous sum at the time​. He invested some of this success in building a splendid home called Grim’s Dyke in Harrow Weald (designed by Norman Shaw) where he entertained the Prince of Wales and other distinguished guests. Goodall’s social and financial success was a testament to how well his vision of the Orient resonated with the Victorian public.

Establishing a Victorian Vision of the East

Within the Orientalist movement, Goodall is remembered for the particular gentleness and dignity with which he portrayed his Eastern subjects. In contrast to certain French Orientalist painters who often focused on harem intrigues or Oriental decadence, Goodall’s paintings are notably wholesome and life-affirming. He emphasized common humanity – mothers and children, honest laborers, devoted pilgrims – and thus his art avoided some of the more lurid clichés of the genre. This humane approach influenced younger artists and contemporaries alike. For example, Bridgman, who traveled to Algeria and Egypt a bit later, also painted ethnographic scenes with careful detail; one can see echoes of Goodall’s ethos in Bridgman’s bustling market and domestic scenes. Goodall’s friend Carl Haag likewise continued to produce watercolors of Middle Eastern life that shared Goodall’s respect for accuracy. Even painters who never traveled relied on Goodall’s works as references for Eastern settings. In essence, Goodall’s paintings became part of the visual repository of “Oriental” imagery in the Victorian imagination.

A Gentle Orientalist Among His Peers

In the broader scope of Victorian painting, Goodall occupies an interesting position. He straddled the line between genre painting and history painting. His early rural works were solid genre pieces, and his later biblical-oriental scenes carried the weight of historical art. By merging the two – treating a contemporary Egyptian scene with the epic significance of history, or infusing a biblical scene with real-life detail – he pioneered a hybrid approach. This was quite in keeping with Victorian intellectual trends, which often tried to reconcile faith with empirical observation. Goodall’s art gave viewers the feeling that they could “visit” the biblical world through the accurate depiction of Eastern locales and peoples, an experience both educational and inspirational. This made his work popular not just as decoration but as didactic art in an era hungry for connection to the ancient past.

From Acclaim to Obscurity — and Back Again

However, as the 19th century gave way to the 20th, artistic fashions changed. The rise of Impressionism and modern art movements made Goodall’s meticulously rendered scenes seem old-fashioned to some. After 1900, Orientalist painting in Britain waned in popularity, and Goodall’s fortunes declined. In fact, despite earlier wealth, he faced financial troubles and was declared bankrupt in 1902. He died two years later in 1904, at the age of 82, and was buried in London’s Highgate Cemetery​. For a time after his death, Goodall’s work (and Orientalist art in general) was less in vogue, sometimes dismissed as Victorian curiosities.

In recent decades, however, there has been a revival of interest in Orientalist art and a reappraisal of its creators. Goodall’s paintings have enjoyed renewed attention from collectors, scholars, and museum curators, particularly as Middle Eastern collectors have shown enthusiasm for 19th-century depictions of their regions. Exhibitions on Orientalism have featured Goodall as an important British contributor to the genre. His canvases, when they appear at auction, often fetch significant prices and travel internationally for exhibitions. In academic circles, art historians like Briony Llewellyn have studied Goodall’s works in the context of imperialism and cross-cultural exchange, recognizing both their artistic merit and their cultural significance. 

At the same time, Goodall’s legacy is intertwined with the complexities of the Orientalist genre. Modern critics, informed by the postcolonial insights of writer Edward Said, have scrutinized Orientalist paintings for the ways they represent “the East” through a Western lens. In Goodall’s case, his honest intent and field-based accuracy set him apart from more fanciful Orientalists, yet his work still reflects the colonial era assumptions of his time. The Egypt that Goodall painted was largely under Ottoman rule and on the cusp of British control (British troops occupied Egypt in 1882, during Goodall’s later years), and his Victorian audience viewed these scenes with a sense of imperial curiosity and confidence. Some scholars argue that even the most sympathetic Orientalist art can make its subjects appear exotic or “other.” As the Khan Academy notes, such art can “make everything seem exotic and alien”, emphasizing differences in a way that reinforces stereotypes. 

Modern Reappraisal and Continuing Influence

Goodall’s paintings, with their picturesque serenity, certainly present an idealized vision of Egypt – one largely absent of the political turmoil or social issues of the time. We do not see British soldiers or overt signs of Western influence in his work; instead, Egypt is portrayed as a biblical land preserved in time. This was partly an artistic choice to appeal to escapist tastes, but it was also a product of 19th-century attitudes.

Yet, it’s important to handle this observation thoughtfully and respectfully. Goodall, like many Orientalist painters, sincerely admired the cultures he painted even as he filtered them through his own cultural perspective. His art does not ridicule or demean its subjects – on the contrary, it often elevates them with a kind of noble idealism. We can acknowledge today that paintings like Goodall’s are “romanticised, exotic” imaginings of the Middle East​, shaped by their era’s limited understanding, while also appreciating their aesthetic beauty and the genuine cross-cultural fascination they embody. Goodall’s canvases preserved visual records of architecture, attire, and customs that have since changed or disappeared, giving them ethnographic as well as artistic value. They continue to be studied not only as art but as historical images of 19th-century Egypt.

Photograph of Goodall in later Life

Conclusion

In summary, Frederick Goodall’s legacy is twofold. On one hand, he left behind a remarkable portfolio of art that delights the eye and testifies to a life of adventure and devotion to craft. On the other hand, his work stands as a case study in the 19th century’s artistic engagement with the “Orient” – an engagement full of creativity and passion, yet intertwined with the perspectives of a colonial age. Goodall’s paintings still hang in museums and collections around the world, admired for their informative detail, luminous color, and heartfelt storytelling. As interest in Orientalist art endures, Goodall remains a key figure who helped define how Victorian Britain saw Egypt and the East. His warm vision of camels by the Nile at sunset, of Pharaoh’s daughter in an Egyptian marsh, or of a humble prayer in the desert, continues to cast a spell – inviting us, as viewers, to step into a bygone world of Eastern encounters and find both insight and enchantment there.

Recent posts

Frederic Arthur Bridgman: Sunlit Splendor in Orientalist Art The Collector’s Canvas: Art & Artists Worth Knowing

Frederic Arthur Bridgman: Sunlit Splendor in Orientalist Art

Edwardian Jewelry: A Glittering Era of Elegance and Craftsmanship The Collector’s Vault: Jewelry Designers Worth Knowing

Edwardian Jewelry: A Glittering Era of Elegance and Craftsmanship

Victorian Jewelry: From Romantic Sentiments to Aesthetic Allure The Collector’s Vault: Jewelry Designers Worth Knowing

Victorian Jewelry: From Romantic Sentiments to Aesthetic Allure

"Oasis on the Edge of the Desert"

Available Exclusively on WorthAntiques.com

Further Reading

For those interested in learning more about Frederick Goodall and Orientalist art, the following sources offer valuable information and perspectives:

  • Frank F. Gibson & Briony Llewellyn, “Goodall, Frederick,” Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (2004) – An authoritative biographical entry providing an overview of Goodall’s life and work. Llewellyn in particular is a scholar of Victorian Orientalist painters.
  • Frederick Goodall, R.A., The Reminiscences of Frederick Goodall, R.A. (1902) – Goodall’s own memoir, which includes anecdotes about his training, travels in Egypt, and the Victorian art world. This first-hand account offers insight into his intentions and experiences.
  • “Frederick Goodall RA, 1822–1904” – The Victorian Web : An online article discussing Goodall’s career in the context of Victorian painting. It provides analysis of his major works and the exhibition history (“Eastern Encounters”) that showcased his Egyptian scenes.
  • Dahesh Museum of Art: Goodall’s Egyptian Pilgrims Arriving at an Inn – Object essay (available on daheshmuseum.org) about one of Goodall’s paintings in the Dahesh collection. It discusses Goodall’s technique and the appeal of his Orientalist imagery to the Victorian public​. 
  • Briony Llewellyn, Eastern Encounters: Orientalist Painters of the Nineteenth Century (1978) – An exhibition catalog from The Fine Art Society, London, which includes Goodall among other Orientalists. It provides historical context and images, and is one of the early modern studies re-evaluating Orientalist art.
  • Nicholas Tromans, ed., The Lure of the East: British Orientalist Painting (Yale University Press, 2008) – A comprehensive book published for a Tate Britain exhibition. Contains essays on the themes of Orientalism in British art, with mentions of Goodall and his contemporaries, plus high-quality reproductions of many paintings.

By exploring these resources, collectors and scholars can further appreciate Frederick Goodall’s place in art history – as a devoted Victorian artist-adventurer whose canvas captured the light and life of the Orient, even as the meaning of those images continues to be interpreted through new lenses today.


Citations: Frederick Goodall’s quotes and historical details have been drawn from reputable sources, including museum collection notes, the artist’s memoirs, and scholarly analyses​. All embedded artwork images are in the public domain and serve to illustrate Goodall’s discussed works visually.

Back to blog